In the fall of 1920 Twinsburg’s spiritual needs were met by two churches that had existed almost as long as the community itself. At that time the two churches merged and most of the small community united under one church. The spiritual leader of the First Congregational Church during the merger was Rev. William C. H. Moe, who published books during his lifetime on the history of The Congregational Churches, churches in the Western Reserve and church music. In 1960 he wrote Seeing it Through, An Autobiography of Rev. William C. H. Moe, D.D. On pages 76 through 81 Rev. Moe, who was also the Twinsburg correspondent to the Hudson newspaper that most Twinsburg residents used to obtain their news, tells the story of how the merger came about:
For nearly 100 years two church organizations–Congregational and Methodist–had
ministered to the spiritual interests of the Twinsburg people. The church buildings
stood about 150 feet apart. Before I arrived as pastor, there had been some discussion
about the possible union of the two churches into a Federated Church. The plan of a
Federated Church was finally abandoned and, since the Congregational Church was a
stronger organization than the Methodist, the members of the latter were quite willing
to become Congregationalists. The people arrived at this decision by themselves.
One thing which led to their final decision for a united work was the frequent change
of pastors in the Methodist Church, Too frequently, desirable young ministers were
transferred to larger churches, and older, less able men sent in their places.
In November, 1920, when I cams as pastor, the Methodist members decided to worship
with the Congregationalists, and Reverend Cobbledick, their minister, having no
congregation, came with them, He continued to occupy the Methodist parsonage and
did considerable visiting among Methodist members. At Easter in 1921 I received into
the Congregational Church all Methodist members and a large number of others by
letter and on confession of faith—102 in all. Dr. R. T. Cross, the pastor emeritus,
shared with me the joy or receiving them. They came forward in four groups, each
group extending from one side of the church to the other.
What was done with the Methodist property? Since it was legally held in the name of
the Conference, it was sold and the proceeds went to the Conference. The Congregational
Church auditorium and parlors were spacious and there was ample room for the enlarged
church membership. The new members were very generous and talented and no church
group in my 57 years was more harmonious.
Ironically, Rev. Moe only stayed in Twinsburg a few years before taking over a much larger church in Connecticut, where he remained for years. In his short time in Twinsburg Rev Moe took part in the newly formed Chamber of Commerce. serving as its treasurer. He was also the president of the local library association and was news correspondent to the Hudson newspaper.